Ongoing Trial of Joslin Smith's Disappearance: Second Witness Provides Crucial Testimony

The Saldanha Bay Circuit High Court in the Western Cape has become the epicenter of a closely watched trial involving the disappearance of seven-year-old Joslin Smith, who went missing on February 19th, 2024. The case has gripped the local community and observers nationwide due to its disturbing nature and the mysterious circumstances surrounding the young child’s disappearance.

On a significant day in court, a second witness, Constable Luzuko Kobese, took the stand to deliver his testimony. His account primarily supported that of his partner, Sergeant Gongota, pertaining to the events of that harrowing night when Joslin was reported missing.

Joslin’s mother, Kelly Smith, her boyfriend Jacquen Appollis, and Steveno van Rhyn face charges of kidnapping and trafficking.

All three accused pleaded 'not guilty' on Monday.

Gongotha is now being cross-examined about his testimony. #sabcnews pic.twitter.com/YGirDUhoJW

— Sphiwe Hobasi (@MrCow_man) March 4, 2025

Constable Kobese detailed to the court how they received an urgent communication from the police station about the missing child. Upon arriving at the Middelpos informal settlement, they were flagged down by Joslin’s distraught mother, Kelly Smith. Despite the gravity of her report, Kobese noted Kelly Smith’s unusually calm demeanor, an observation that aligns with his colleague’s previous testimony and could paint a complicated picture for the court.

The legal proceedings have seen Joslin's mother, alongside co-accused Jacquen Appolis and Steveno Van Rhyn, maintain their innocence against all charges. The dynamic in the courtroom has been tense, with the defense and prosecution fiercely contesting each aspect of the testimonies provided.

NPA Spokesperson Eric Ntabazalila underscored the importance of the testimonies of the officers as they establish a timeline and the initial reactions of the first respondents to the scene.

Presiding over the case, Judge Nathan Erasmus highlighted the severe implications of the charges, referencing Section 51 (1) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act — commonly known as the minimum sentences act. This law could lead to life imprisonment for the accused if convicted of count one or any alternative charges related to the disappearance.

As the trial progresses, the community remains hopeful for answers about what exactly happened to Joslin Smith on that fateful February night. The emotional toll on the family and the Middelpos community is palpable, with each day in court unraveling more layers of this distressing case.

The outcome of the trial could potentially set significant legal precedents regarding child disappearance cases in South Africa, emphasizing the judiciary's role in addressing and adjudicating such sensitive matters.